Writers' News

For a wide range of services for writers, visit our links page

Writing Magazine

Competition Showcase | Online competition | WN competitions | WM competitions | Rules

Competition Showcase – Questions by Mary Clarke

 

About Mary Clarke
Mary Clarke lives in West Yorkshire, with her fifteen year old son, where she works
as a doctor in a local hospice. She is a member of the Airedale Writers’ Circle, which meets once a month: ‘I started writing during a career break,’ she says. ‘It has been hard work transferring skills from writing bullet points to ‘painting with words’ but I have had a lot of fun, especially when one of my stories was read out on Radio Four.

Questions

by Mary Clarke



I don’t know what I imagined. To find him waiting for me, to take up where we left off? No, I don’t think so. He is gone from this world, I’m sure of that… although I never got to bury his body. What then? To be nearer to him, to walk where he did? Maybe. Even I don’t know really know the answers. A remote group of islands, wind-swept and 8000 miles from the nearest British port and 200 miles from Argentina; why would anyone want to come here in the first place?
We set off at first light, Lizzibeth and I, for the drive to the airport. She wanted to come with me, but I said I would rather not have anyone to talk to. I didn’t want to share this anniversary with a group of widows. This was my adventure, my pilgrimage. They’d understand. I’m sure they would. What is it like to be a war widow, Emily? What is it like to be a seashell on the shore? We all of us resemble each other, until you get close. Don’t make any assumptions about me, please.
He was a good husband, my husband, one of the best. In the mornings he held my body and stroked my hair, and the in evenings… well. And he cared for his men - too much I think sometimes. I booked myself on a cruise, a trip around the ‘Fjords of the South’. I could have gone on to Antarctica, seen the whales and the penguins… but to do that, I would have to go to Argentina.
The British army landed at San Carlos Bay on East Falkland in May 1982 and the weather was already bitterly cold. They suffered badly crossing the long stretches of exposed moorland and mountains to Port Stanley. The Argentine soldiers waited for them, many didn’t even know where they were or why they were there, and no one had believed that Britain would fight back. All that way? It was madness. But they had reckoned without the ‘Iron Lady’ and she did fight back, in a big way; she launched the Task Force and sank the Belgrano even though it was outside of the Exclusion Zone.
Here is a boat, still floating, thankfully, a pleasant fishing boat that now doubles a cruise ship. It must be hard making a living down here and yet the people look happy enough, happy with their Britishness. ‘The Falklands War’ was not the first time the sovereignty of these islands has been in dispute, you know. Practically ever since European eyes first fell upon them, they have been fought over. Strategy is apparently what it is called. If you mean to sail around the world, then they come in handy. Some people say the war was the making of the British Nation, that it had forgotten who it was. I have to admit to being impressed. All those ships refitted in record time and on their way to the South Atlantic, cruise liners turned into aircraft carriers, aeroplanes re-fuelling in mid-air. Ah, the glory of war. And we won, we won!
Well, we lost, too. Young men, suckled tenderly by their mothers, grown strong with their love, filled with their pride – then sacrificed to the great god of war and turned into so much scrap. How heart breaking it is. I never saw his body again. To have cared for every bit of him, known every stretch of skin, and have it taken away without the chance to say goodbye. Oh, I have cried. I have cried in the night and he has come to me and wrapped me in his presence so that I am hushed, comforted; but when the dawn comes it starts again. Life without him. The show ended twenty-five years ago but I can’t seem to get off the stage. How much longer am I supposed to stand here and wonder what happened? Why can’t anyone tell me how he died? Was nobody else there?
A seal, basking on the seashore. On land a loafing oaf, in the sea, a ballerina. Look how he slides through the water and ‘splash’, he jumps for joy. And what a joy it is, I can just about remember, I think. How I wish that God had seen fit to grant us a child, someone who could bear his name, perhaps wear his eyes so that I could look into them and be sure that he existed.
Over there, on that hill, a skull and cross bones shouts a warning to us. Not of pirates sailing up the Falkland Sound but of a cowardly menace, hidden in the peaty, boggy soil, bringing death or worse to those unwary enough to stray near it. We tourists have been warned to keep away from the minefields; the Falkland Islanders have to live with them. Did the men who put them in the ground think about the days when they would wish the ground to be free of them again? Or were they ‘just obeying orders’? Perhaps they were some of the Argentine conscripts who spent their war starving and freezing. There was food, but in the end it was the British soldiers who gave it to them. What way is that to win a war? Like a gigantic football match, both sides struggle for victory, but in the end it seems that it is only the final score that counts.
Well this time the final score was one-nil, no more, to Britain, and her soldiers returned home, riding high on the decks of the huge ships that carried them. The ports were jammed with well wishers waving Union Jacks. And the Argentines? Some soldiers say they were left at the quayside to make their own way home. Some say they even had to beg for bus fare. Win or lose, it must have been bewildering. I heard that since the war, more soldiers have committed suicide on both sides than were killed in the conflict. It seems that for some of us, the fighting never stopped.
I asked everyone I knew how he died, but no one could tell me. Once or twice, I thought I was getting somewhere; an odd hesitation, a glance sliding sideways. I asked the colonels and the sergeants and everybody I could think of in between, but always the same answer, a sad shake of the head. And then the anger exploded in my breast, somebody must have seen! Or at least, somebody found his body. How did he die? What were his injuries? Was he shot to pieces, blown up, drowned? If there was enough of his body left to identify him, why not enough to say how he died?
The air down here is fresh, and the wind never stops blowing. These islands witness the beauty of the waves but they also witness barbarity; whales slaughtered for profit, men slaughtered for political gain. In ‘The Falklands War’ both leaders needed to boost their popularity, but only one succeeded. Margaret Thatcher became the darling of Britain, but it was the end for General Galtieri. Such a strange place to pick a fight for popularity. Wild islands, tiny compared to the vast ocean in which they sit and so, so remote. Surely if the Falklands belong to anyone, they belong to God, and in that way they belong to us all.
In the days following the end of the war I had to make a decision. Britain entered a period of feel good prosperity, Argentina brooded. My questions and my nationality made me unpopular. I was getting nearer to the truth and somebody did not like it. One night a man followed me in the dark and beat my body, kicked my head and almost drove the life from my lungs. My teeth snapped, my nose broke and my blood flowed into the gutter. The following day, when I dared to look into the mirror, deep purple flowers had blossomed around my eyes. I knew what I had to do.
But it was hard. To leave meant leaving him and I had made a promise, even though death had released me from it. When I agreed to become his wife, I agreed to become part of his life. What would they think of me where I was going, those women who mourned? I would never be one of them, never be able to share my memories of him without enduring their looks of accusation. I would lose him as surely as if he had never existed.
Perhaps that is why I am here. Somewhere on this craggy island he is buried, even the man who dug the hole cannot tell me where, because he perished too - or so they said. I am sixty now, and the dark haired beauty who caught my husband’s eye is just a memory. In a quiet moment I call out his name, but the wind whips the words away from my mouth. You see, the problem is, I was born in Britain, but my husband was born in Argentina.


Judging comment
Mary Clarke’s story adds up to a single question: Is there any winner in war? Our heroine’s husband was on the ‘wrong side’ – which means the side that lost. But long before we reach the end of the story we learn that he was also something much more important: a caring and a cared-for human being.
But he was on the wrong side. Something which becomes only apparent right at the end, when Mary Clarke calls into the question the emotions and the principles that she has built within us, her readers, as we absorb what she has to say about the husband and the quests of this character she has created for us. A simple enough story, but very moving.