Writers' News

For a wide range of services for writers, visit our links page

Writing Magazine

Competition Showcase | Online competition | WN competitions | WM competitions | Rules

Competition Showcase – Playground Duty by Alyson Hilbourne

 

About Alyson Hilbourne
‘I am a successful "nearly but not quite" writer,’ says Alyson. She has been shortlisted in several Writers’ News competitions, and has now achieved second place on two occasions. She has also been shortlisted in an article writing competition and in a children's story writing competition.

Alyson lives in Thailand with her family where her husband is a maths teacher and she is a learning support assistant in an International School. They have also lived in Hong Kong, Vienna, Amsterdam and Sri Lanka.

‘I should really like to write for children and completed the Writer's News Writing for Children Home Study course a couple of years back which I enjoyed very much,’ says Alison. ‘I have a several unpublished children's stories gathering dust on the computer.’

Playground Duty

by Alyson Hilbourne



An invisible umbilical cord is keeping them together.
The shared past binds them.
She wants to leave. She has wanted to go for a long time, since before that day. Now every playground duty is a nightmare, and today it is made worse by a thin January drizzle. Even so, the idea of breaking free is daunting.
What will the press say if they find she is leaving? After so much coverage someone will let slip that she has handed in her notice. This is a worry to her. She doesn’t want it to appear everything is too much for her. It would annoy her if people said the pressure was too much. Maybe she can take sick leave? The problem is she exudes good health. It was one of the things the photographers had loved about her.
But they don’t know about the nights, when she wakes up sweating, her heart racing, her muscles tense ready to flee. His face taunts her even during sleep. She feels his hot meaty breath on her neck, and the scalding of the knife as it is pressed against her throat. She hears the bronchial whistle as he breaths and the rasp of his voice so close to her ear she feels the words. She has to turn on the light to check no one is there, and crawl shaking out of bed and downstairs where, if she is lucky, she can doze on the sofa until morning.
Her photo appeared on the front page of every newspaper in the country, and the television stations rushed to film her after it happened. She became the country’s darling but it didn’t protect her from the nightmares.
At school the memories are vivid too. She is suspicious of everybody who approaches. It would be unreasonable to stop people walking across the playground to the front door. Parents did it every morning and every afternoon but each visitor sends her heart racing and sets her brain questioning.
No one had noticed anything unusual last term when the man had crossed the playground, twisting between the jump ropes and games of soccer, and approached the door. He could have been anyone’s parent. The jacket, jeans, cap and stubble didn’t mark him out as a problem, and he wouldn’t have been the first estranged father that had come storming into the school demanding access to his children.
But this man had no connection with the school. He was apparently unhappy because he couldn’t get a job, and he blamed it on his poor education. But as the papers pointed out, people don’t go into Tesco brandishing a knife if they get a bad yogurt. Why did this man take his grievances out on the nearest educational establishment?
She had been on playground duty, just like today. She saw him as he strode across the tarmac and rang the doorbell, but she’d thought nothing of it. People were always coming and going. Some of the children had been playing on the steps near him. When he got no answer, he grabbed young Caitlin.
She was surprised.
Shocked.
Horrified.
Each emotion rose up in her like a wave flooding the last. It had taken a few moments for her to realise what was happening. That sort of thing happened in movies, not in a school playground.
There was a scream, and she saw a glint of metal under Caitlin’s chin.
Two girls came rushing away from the steps but Susie stood there, frozen, her eyes wide with fear. The girls grabbed her skirt, preventing her from moving. She patted their backs to reassure them but kept her eyes fixed on the steps.
‘Go round to the back of the school,’ she had whispered, firmly. ‘Tell Ms Kemp there is someone out here with a knife.’ She gently removed the small fingers from her jacket and pushed the girls in the right direction.
She took a deep breath. Instinct told her to blow the whistle and herd all the children round the back, but her eyes stayed on Caitlin who was whimpering miserably, her thin white legs swinging loosely in the air like cooked spaghetti, as the man held her up.
She worried that someone inside might open the door and scare him. She wanted to call Susie away but didn’t want to provoke him.
Gradually the rest of the children, like a ripple spreading out across water, noticed that something was happening. They stopped playing and drew closer as if pulled by some gravitational force. Quietly but urgently, she urged them to go to the back of the school.
‘Go to Mr Mason’s class,’ she whispered, but they seemed reluctant to move, hypnotised to the action. She didn’t want to make a fuss and attract attention. She tried to beckon Susie away, but the child remained on the steps, not realising the danger, watching her friend. Caitlin was tearful.
She tried to calm her own fear. Her heart was thumping and her mouth tasted sour. She could see the knife, the point resting just above Caitlin’s fluorescent pink scarf.
‘Let her go!’ she called. Her throat was dry and her voice squeaked.
‘Let her go. She’s only five years old,’ She tried again.
The man didn’t seem to hear.
‘What do you want? Who are you looking for?’
‘Let me in,’ he answered.
‘I can’t. The door is on a security lock. Someone has to release it from inside.’
‘Tell them then. Come here and tell them to let me in!’
He was breathing fast and gabbling. Whatever he wanted she had the feeling it wasn’t supposed to take place here on the school steps. He was nervous.
‘OK, OK,’ she made a calming motion with her hands. ‘If I come will you let the child go?’
He shrugged but didn’t answer, so she forced herself to walk as calmly as she could up the steps. She could feel her stomach was churning and bile flooded the back of her throat, her body warning her of danger. Her legs felt wobbly but she fought back the urge to run. She scanned the windows of the school searching for a sign that somebody knew what was going on before she stepped into the shadow of the porch.
Caitlin almost leapt into her arms as she was released, but immediately she felt a tight grip on her upper arm and the cold metal on her neck between her hair and the top of her jacket sent a shiver down her back.
‘Run,’ she said to Caitlin, but the child was shaking and weeping and refused to move.
She didn’t know how long she stood there. He held her close with one arm across her neck, protecting himself with her body. Her skin burned where the knife touched it. She prayed her legs wouldn’t give way and she’d fall. She kept her breathing as shallow as possible, and tried not to make a sound. She hoped Caitlin wouldn’t pull her suddenly but the child seemed content just to hang on to her hand, her other fingers bunched up in her mouth.
‘Goal!’
The cheer snaps her back into the present and she shakes her head to clear the thoughts. There is nobody there, just the sound of children shouting to each other and the scudding of the football across the tarmac.
A helicopter comes into view, its blades chopping the air with a regular beat. It banks away and flies over the trees at the far side of the playground. Just some voyeurs, she thinks, wanting to see where the action had been.
Distant police sirens spin her thoughts back to that day however and the time she spent held on the steps, watching as the police built up a cordon around the school and a different helicopter flew backwards and forwards overhead.
She hadn’t seen the children leave, but she’d been told later the whole school had all been led to safety though the back and had climbed ladders over the rear fence, where buses waited to take them away. The police had bombarded the man with messages through a loudhailer. Susie was coaxed away and eventually a policewoman had been allowed close enough to prize Caitlin away, gently lifting each finger in turn and carrying her towards her mother who waited at the police lines. She’d felt a tremor of despair then, as if part of her had been snatched away.
Then, as the policemen shouted another message there had been a crash and the doors behind her burst open, hitting her, and knocking them both to the ground. The knife tore down her arm, splitting her jacket and slicing the flesh wide and red.
The pain was excruciating. She wanted to scream but she felt numb, as if in some horrific operation where she could feel what was happening but could do nothing about it.
Three, four, five policemen in a flurry of black and silver bore down on them both and hauled the man to his feet, knocking the knife from his hand. She was led away to an ambulance, bulbs flashing as the press snapped away.
She had been put up for awards. She’d had meetings with important people. There were the masses and masses of cards, letters and emails she had received from ordinary people thanking her for her act of heroism.
Shuddering she tries to shake off the vision, but the image won’t clear. Playground duty has become something she dreads with her every waking minute.
That’s why she has to do something. As the drizzle ratchets up to heavy rain she decides. She owes it to herself. She is not doing herself any favours staying where she doesn’t want to be. Whatever people think of her, she is going to follow her dream. She will hand in her notice and post the application for voluntary service. She can shake off the fears, and travel. Then she’ll teach for a while wherever she is needed and sort out her future from there.
She blows the whistle and signals the children inside out of the rain, grateful that playground duty is over for another day.


Judging comment
Playground duty is over for another day.

The brief for this short story competition was that the stories should have duty as their theme. And supervising the playground certainly qualifies as duty. The teacher stands there with a responsibility for the safety of a playground full of children involved in activities that are not necessarily safe.

But for Alyson Hilbourne’s teacher, playground duty became quite literally a nightmare. Indeed, well after the event, she still has her nightmares. And that is central to the question that Alyson’s stories raises: What happens to heroes after the media has got bored with them and moved on to newer stories and people? The after effects don’t conveniently move on as the cameramen go away. They say that the best short stories should say something about the human condition. Alyson Hilbourne’s story certainly qualifies on that score.